Download the constitutional court nkandla judgment corruption. Ad hoc committees feedback on nkandla enca livestream. Before the establishment of the ad hoc committee, it was reported that the president had decided that he would respond to the report of the public protector, after certain further investigations had been conducted by the special investigating unit siu. The ad hoc committee s report contains the following recommendations. The ad hoc committee on the palestinian question, also known as the ad hoc committee on palestine or just the ad hoc committee was a committee formed by a vote of the united nations general assembly on 23 september 1947, following the publication of the report of the united nations special committee on palestine unscop on 3 september 1947, which contained majority and minority proposals. Parliament, thursday, 06 august 2015 the ad hoc committee on police ministers nkandla report has today adopted its report which will be tabled in the national assembly this friday, 07 august 2015. Jacob zumas lavish nkandla estate described as obscene. Jun 03, 2015 a motion by opposition parties to block the establishing of a second adhoc committee enquiry into the upgrades at president jacob zumas private nkandla home, was struck off the programme after the ruling african national congress anc used its majority vote. Ad hoc committee on police ministers report on nkandla. The first part addresses itself to the legality and constitutionality of the process that has culminated in the appointment of the ad hoc committee.
Ad hoc committee on minister of police report on nkandla committee programme. The new ad hoc committee process has not changed the original position of the udm that the president must not use the executive and parliament to undermine the report of the public protector, but should in line with legal prescripts. Final ad hoc committee report free download as word doc. Mps argue over new nkandla ad hoc committee s tasks. Submission of the opposition parties to the ad hoc committee. The anc and da have locked horns over whether to allow the new nkandla ad hoc committee to consider reports from the public protector and the. Jul 31, 2015 if you thought the latest nkandla parliamentary ad hoc committee was about whether president jacob zuma should pay back the money, you were very wrong. Da mp john steenhuisen had asked for an amendment to the report and provided at least 20 changes but this was rejected by the majority of members the ad hoc committee had earlier in the month given its approval to police minister nathi nhlekos report on the nkandla homestead, despite objections from its opposition members. The joint standing committee on intelligence task team report and parliaments ad hoc report on nkandla do not explicitly contest this assessment. We have confirmed this morning that the anc have yet to submit the names. Mps argue over new nkandla ad hoc committees tasks news.
Parliaments ad hoc committee on nkandla in kzn for. Democratic alliance v speaker of the national assembly and others 2016 zacc 11 is a major judgment of the constitutional court of south africa which finds that president jacob zuma breached the south african constitution by failing to implement the recommendations in the public protectors nkandla report. Parliaments ad hoc committee, tasked with dealing with the various reports on the nkandla spending scandal, convenes for its second session. Jacob zumas lavish nkandla estate described as obscene by mp inspectors.
The nkandla report by thuli madonsela on jacob zumas homestead and the corrupt practices involved there. Read the public protectors full nkandla report the citizen. The ad hoc committee was set up in june to consider police minister nathi nhlekos report into upgrades at president jacob zumas nkandla residence. It is our view that this visit, following the scandalous nhleko report, is a. You may watch a recording of the proceedings in the gallery above. The ad hoc committee has its origin in assembly resolution 2186 2017 on a call for a council of. Secure in comfort is my report as the public protector of the republic of. Ad hoc committee on the palestinian question wikipedia. The private home of former south african president jacob zuma, situated about 24 km 15 mi. Ad hoc committee on police ministers report on nkandla pmg.
Download the constitutional court nkandla judgment. A special parliamentary ad hoc committee releases a report exonerating zuma from paying for nonsecurity related features at nkandla on the basis that they were broadly speaking security features. Pdf icon report by the minister of police to parliament on. In 2015 the current leader of the opposition moved a motion in the national assembly for the establishment of an ad hoc committee to determine.
Announcements, tablings and committee reports no 912014 committee reports national assembly report of the ad hoc committee to consider the report by the president regarding the security upgrades at the nkandla private residence of the president, dated 11 november 2014 having considered the report of the president, the reports and. A second parliamentary ad hoc committee, established in august 2014, would consider the report of the interministerial task team published in december 20, the public protectors final report published in march 2014 and the sius report published in september 2014, as well as zumas responses to them. Constitution in regard to his role in the nkandla project. After deliberations this morning the caucus resolved as follows regarding the nkandla ad hoc committee. Regarding the issue of legal authority to install security features at a. Durban members of parliaments ad hoc committee on nkandla are being. The report can only be deliberated upon in the national assembly once the programming committee has factored this into the nas programme.
Pietermaritzburg parliaments ad hoc committee on nkandla will conduct an inloco inspection of president jacob zumas private home in rural kwazulunatal today but the committee says it doesn. Indian constitution mentions two kinds of parliamentary committees standing committees and ad hoc committees. Public protector expected the adhoc committee on nkandla. Executive summary of the research report introduction and rationale this analysis of the news coverage relating to the expenditure on president zumas private home at nkandla is undertaken under the auspices of the media policy and democracy project, a joint collaborative research initiative between the department of. Last week the anc members of parliament adopted a report that exonerates president jacob zuma of all wrongdoing in the r250 million nkandla scandal. These instructions state that publications in research and other creative accomplishment. Ad hoc committee on minister of police report on nkandla. Report of the ad hoc committee to consider the report by the president regarding the security upgrades at the nkandla private residence of the president, dated 11 november 2014 having considered the report of the president, the reports and correspondence presented before it on the security upgrades at the nkandla private residence of the. Am live on safm, 4 aug 7am thuli madonsela still wants to appear before nkandla ad hoc committee safm public protector advocate thuli madonsela says the speaker of the national assembly baleka mbete is duty bound in terms of the constitution to allow her to shed light on police minister ntahi nhlekos report before the parliamentary ad hoc committee on nkandla. Anc distances itself from chief whips comments on nkandla. Calls for establishment of ad hoc committee as presidents nkandla report tabled aug. A meeting of the ad hoc committee presidents submission in response to public protectors report on nkandla committee held on 11.
Gubula said the committee members from all parties found that there were was gross exaggeration of the scope, scale and cost of the nkandla project and that south africans were misled about the opulence of the private residence of the president. That ah committee had been established but did not complete task when parliament was dissolved for 2014 general election. The committee on academic personnel wishes to direct the attention of ad hoc committee members to two statements contained in the instructions to appointment and promotion committees. Why report of nkandla ad hoc committee is of no legal relevance. Parliamentary committees upsc exam preparation indian. Adhoc committee debates nkandla from parliament cape town.
The da has voted against the establishment of an ad hoc committee that is to consider police minister nathi nhlekos report on security upgrades to president jacob zumas private home at nkandla. Programme of ad hoc committee to consider report by president. The committee is due to report back to parliament by. A report of the public protector found that zuma unduly benefited from these improvements and. In 2014, loto had filed motion in na for establishment of an ad hoc committee to determine whether jz had committed a serious violation with regard to his role in nkandla project. Economic freedom fighters v speaker of the national assembly. Pdf nkandla and affirmative action, business day 2015. Adhoc committee debates nkandla 26 september 2014 part 2. Apr 24, 2014 opposition parties argued that president jacob zuma and public protector thuli madonsela should appear before the ad hoc committee set up to consider his response to her findings on the nkandla.
Document the national assembly na programme committee at its regular meeting this morning agreed to establish a joint ad hoc committee, comprising. Responding to a question on what her side of the story on nkandla was since it looked as though the parliamentary ad hoc committee on the matter was not going to allow her to be interviewed on her report, the public protector she had expected parliament to allow her to shed light on the issues contained in the report. A meeting of the ad hoc committee presidents submission in response to public protectors report on nkandla committee held on 17 september 2014, lead by mr c frolick anc. Report of the ad hoc committee to consider the report of the minister of police in reply to recommendations in the report of the ad hoc committee to consider the report by the president regarding security upgrades at the nkandla private residence of the president dated 6 august 2015. In the application the applicants as well as the intervening party sought various orders. Opposition parties argued that president jacob zuma and public protector thuli madonsela should appear before the ad hoc committee set up to consider his response to her findings on the nkandla. Report the report contains the following recommendations. And yesterday mps from the ad hoc committee arrived at. Cape town the ad hoc committee on nkandla has resumed its work in parliament by comparing two different investigative reports on the multimillion rand security upgrades to president jacob zuma. Public protector thuli madonselas report on upgrades to zumas nkandla home, sizani added.
The second ad hoc committee challenged the findings of the public protector and referred the. Meetings, calls for comment, reports, and questions and replies of the ad hoc committee on police ministers report on nkandla committee. Mps argue over new nkandla ad hoc committee s tasks andisiwe makinana 19 aug 2014 19. The topic parliamentary committees is important for ias exam and its three stages. If you thought the latest nkandla parliamentary ad hoc committee was about whether president jacob zuma should pay back the money, you were very wrong. Sep 26, 2014 parliaments ad hoc committee, tasked with dealing with the various reports on the nkandla spending scandal, convenes for its second session. Report on an investigation into allegations of impropriety and unethical conduct relating to the installation and implementation of security measures by the department of public works at and in respect of the private residence of president. Submission of the opposition parties to the ad hoc. Corruption watch appeared as amicus curiae friend of the court. Thuli madonsela still wants to appear before nkandla ad. The speaker maintained her position that the national assembly, through setting up ad hoc committees and considering several reports. The report may also deal with whether the security upgrades actually are effective, as the minister was instructed to determine by the parliamentary nkandla ad hoc committee late last year.
Aug 19, 2015 nobody should be surprised that parliament gave its ad hoc committees nkandla report the stamp of approval. On 19 march 2014, she released her socalled nkandla report, which found. Economic freedom fighters v speaker of the national assembly and others. Parliaments ad hoc committee on nkandla is set to conduct an inloco inspection of president jacob zumas controversial kwazulunatal homestead. The committee was established to look into the report by the police minister, nathi nhleko, on how much money president jacob zuma should repay for non security upgrades. The committee has until friday to submit its report, but mps remain divided over zumas financial liability. Da asks for extension of nkandla ad hoc committee deadline by businesslive. The paper reports that parliament ad hoc committee on nkandla received a formal complaint from one such group calling itself concerned lawyers and. Nkandla adhoc committee to visit zumas homestead news24. Report of the ad hoc committee to consider the report of the minister of police in reply to recommendations in the report of the ad hoc committee to consider the report by the president regarding security upgrades at the nkandla private residence of. Adhoc committee on nkandla as flawed and against the law. That ad hoc committee was established but had not completed its task when parliament was dissolved ahead of the 2014 general election. Parliaments ad hoc committee on nkandla will do an inloco inspection of president jacob zumas controversial nkandla homestead on wednesday.
The president confirmed this in his letter to the speaker dated 01 april 2014. The public protector on wednesday released her longawaited report on the security upgrades at president jacob zumas private nkandla homestead. The national assembly resolved to reestablish an 11member ad hoc committee to consider the nkandla upgrades last tuesday. Opposition blasts approval of second nkandla adhoc committee. The efforts of opposition political parties pushing for the reestablishment of the parliamentary ad hoc committee on the nkandla report might soon.
Parliaments adhoc committee on nkandla is set to conduct an inloco. Sep 26, 2014 ad hoc committee debates nkandla from parliament cape town. Republic of south africa, his excellency j g zuma, at nkandla in the. Casac submission to parliament on work of its nkandla committee. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Final ad hoc committee report committee social institutions scribd. Economic freedom fighters and others v speaker of the. The nkandla ad hoc committee has officially adopted police minister nkosinathi nhlekos report that president jacob zuma will not have to pay back public money spent on his nkandla home.
Calls for establishment of ad hoc committee as presidents. Secure in comfort a report of the march 2014 public protector. Nobody should be surprised that parliament gave its ad hoc committee s nkandla report the stamp of approval. Apr 14, 2014 the da accused the anc on monday 14042014 of deliberately trying to delay the work of the ad hoc committee on nkandla. Why report of nkandla ad hoc committee is of no legal. Parliament on tuesday evening adopted the report by its ad hoc committee on nkandla, which exonerated president jacob zuma from paying for nonsecurity features. Letter from president zuma to advocate madonsela pdf.
Am live on safm, 31 jul 8am ad hoc committee on nkandla elects not to call more witnesses safm parliaments ad hoc committee on nkandla has concluded that it will not call any other witnesses to appear before it. Committee report on report by president on nkandla security. The matter is connected with the nkandla judgment of this court and the presidents failure to implement the public protectors remedial action for some time after the public protector had released her report on the nkandla project. We would like to show you a description here but the site wont allow us. A meeting of the ad hoc committee on police ministers report on nkandla committee held on 23 june 2015, lead by mr c frolick anc. Parliaments ad hoc committee on nkandla is set to conduct an inloco inspection of president.
129 343 362 769 160 1201 533 574 1289 1514 700 286 838 827 1002 1303 1124 274 856 396 446 1078 1088 713 70 909 1229 1338